The Musharraf Era (1999–2008)

🎯

Topic: The Musharraf Era (1999–2008). Covers the takeover, the 7-point agenda, the Devolution Plan, the 2002 referendum and LFO, the 17th Amendment, 9/11 and the War on Terror, Enlightened Moderation, the Lal Masjid tragedy, the judicial crisis, Benazir's assassination, and Musharraf's economic and foreign policies.

CSS relevance: 🔥 Very high. Frequently tested: the 17th Amendment, Devolution of Power Plan / Local Government Ordinance 2000, NRO, Lal Masjid, Enlightened Moderation, and "Critically evaluate Musharraf's rule."

🗺️ Overview

---

I. The Takeover (12 October 1999)

• 12 October 1999: PM Nawaz Sharif attempted to remove Army Chief Musharraf and replace him with Gen. Ziauddin Butt.
• The Army, viewing this as an affront, overthrew Nawaz's government. Nawaz was arrested on plane-hijacking charges, convicted, and later sent into exile.
• Musharraf assumed control as Chief Executive.
• 14 October 1999: issued a Provisional Constitution Order (PCO) suspending the Constitution, but allowed President Rafiq Tarar to continue in office (who completed his constitutional term and then retired).

The 7-point agenda

Musharraf announced seven aims:

1. Rebuild national confidence and morale
2. Strengthen the federation, remove inter-provincial disharmony, restore national cohesion
3. Revive the economy and restore investor confidence
4. Ensure law and order and dispense speedy justice
5. De-politicise state institutions
6. Devolution of power to the grassroots level
7. Ensure swift and across-the-board accountability

The last two points received the most concrete follow-through: a new local government system (devolution) and an Accountability Bureau.

---

II. Judicial Validation of the Coup

• 12 May 2000: the Supreme Court validated the October 1999 takeover under the doctrine of necessity, granting Musharraf executive and legislative authority for 3 years, after which democracy had to be restored.

---

III. Devolution of Power: the Local Government System

• Local Government Ordinance (LGO), 2000 issued; local body elections held in 2001; new local government system installed.
• Key features:
  • Power devolved to the district level.
  • Head of the district: the District Nazim — in charge of law and order, and overseeing all development departments.
  • The Deputy Commissioner's magisterial (judicial) powers were withdrawn and returned to the judiciary — the first-ever separation of the judiciary from the executive at the district level in Pakistan, consistent with Article 175 of the 1973 Constitution.
  • The DC's office was replaced/renamed as District Coordination Officer (DCO), working under the elected District Nazim.
  • Police reforms accompanied this: a new Police Order replaced the colonial-era Police Act of 1861; created a Public Safety Commission, Police Complaints Authority, and Police Management Boards.
• Fate after Musharraf: once his government ended, the PPP government reverted to the old system ("rolled back" the Devolution Plan), and Sindh and Balochistan repealed the Police Order. However, the separation of judiciary from executive persisted.

---

IV. Opposition: the ARD

• 3 December 2000: the two largest parties, PPP and PML-N, formed the Alliance for the Restoration of Democracy (ARD).
• Limited impact: its leadership was in exile, and it failed to generate meaningful political unrest against Musharraf domestically.

---

V. Musharraf Becomes President

• 2001: when Rafiq Tarar's term ended, Musharraf assumed the office of President himself, concentrating both the presidency and Chief Executive powers in one hand.
• 30 April 2002: Musharraf held a referendum to legitimise his rule (the same tactic Zia had used), and became President through it.
• 24 August 2002: issued the Legal Framework Order (LFO) 2002, under which elections were held.

---

VI. 2002 Elections & the LFO

• 10 October 2002: general elections held, meeting the Supreme Court's 3-year deadline.
• PML-Q ("the King's Party," carved out of PML-N) won the most seats.
• Mir Zafarullah Khan Jamali (from Balochistan) became PM.
• Jamali served about 2 years, then had differences with Musharraf and resigned (June 2004).
• Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain briefly served as interim PM, followed by Shaukat Aziz (a technocrat, a non-entity in Pakistani politics before this) becoming PM.
• Chaudhry Pervaiz Elahi became CM Punjab.
• Like Zia's PML before it, Musharraf carved a "King's Party" (PML-Q) out of the mainstream PML-N to govern through hand-picked loyalists.

---

VII. 9/11 and the War on Terror

• After 9/11 (2001): under pressure from US Secretary of State Colin Powell ("you're either with us or against us"), Musharraf agreed to support the US anti-terror campaign.
• This was a major U-turn: Pakistan had previously been allied with the Taliban in Afghanistan.
• Pakistan became a US and NATO ally, later earning "Major Non-NATO Ally" status, and joined operations against the Taliban.
• Consequences for Pakistan:
  • A new wave of terrorism, especially in KP (then NWFP), FATA, and Balochistan.
  • Heavy bloodshed on both sides — many Pakistani soldiers martyred, alongside militant and civilian casualties.
  • Economic, human, and infrastructure losses.
  • Human rights violations: "missing persons" cases, drone strikes (including on madrassas), raising sovereignty concerns.

---

VIII. The Charter of Democracy (2006)

• 14 May 2006, London: Nawaz Sharif (PML-N) and Benazir Bhutto (PPP), both in exile, signed the Charter of Democracy.
• Purpose: outline steps to end military rule established in 1999 and restore civilian democratic rule.

---

IX. The Akbar Bugti Incident (2006)

• 26 August 2006: veteran Baloch politician Nawab Akbar Bugti was killed.
• Impact: severely worsened law and order in Balochistan, gave momentum to existing Baloch grievances, and fuelled a sustained insurgency/struggle against the Musharraf government.

---

X. The Judicial Crisis (2007)

• March 2007: Musharraf dismissed Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, in a bid to dominate the judiciary (Chaudhry had leaned toward anti-government rulings).
• This triggered a massive lawyers' movement, strongly backed by PML-N.
• July 2007: under public pressure, Musharraf was forced to withdraw the order and restore Iftikhar Chaudhry as Chief Justice.

---

XI. Lal Masjid & the Karachi "Black Saturday"

Lal Masjid Tragedy

• 3–10 July 2007: law enforcement besieged Lal Masjid (Red Mosque) in the heart of Islamabad, leading to prolonged fighting.
• Left about nine (officially) to potentially many more people dead, and Islamabad at a standstill for days.
• Fallout: religious militants/Taliban began targeting army installations, sparking a new wave of terrorism in Pakistan.

Karachi "Black Saturday" (12 May 2007)

• Violent clashes erupted between rival political activists when the suspended CJ Iftikhar Chaudhry arrived at Jinnah International Airport, Karachi, to address a rally, which the government opposed.
• MQM (pro-government) clashed with PML-N/pro-judiciary activists; about 58 people were killed.
• Controversially, Musharraf held a large public rally/celebration in Islamabad the same evening, drawing criticism.

---

XII. Benazir Bhutto's Return & Assassination

• October 2007: Benazir Bhutto returned to Pakistan, landing in Karachi after 8 years in exile.
  • On arrival, a first assassination attempt occurred, in which she survived but a large number of people receiving her were killed.
• 2 December 2007 (the lecturer's date; commonly cited as 27 December 2007): a second attack in Rawalpindi succeeded — Benazir Bhutto was assassinated.
  • ⚠️ Note for exams: the widely documented and correct date is 27 December 2007 — verify this against standard references, as the lecture's stated date appears to be an error.
• This was a massive shock to Pakistani politics, and a major destabilising event heading into the 2008 elections.

---

XIII. Emergency, Dissolution & the 2008 Elections

• November 2007: Musharraf imposed a state of emergency; most senior Supreme Court judges were removed/restrained.
• The National Assembly completed its 5-year term and was dissolved (Nov 2007); Muhammad Mian Soomro became caretaker PM.
• Nawaz Sharif also returned to Pakistan in November 2007, after 7 years of forced exile.
• Because of the law-and-order crisis following Benazir's assassination, elections were postponed and eventually held on 18 February 2008.

Election results (National Assembly)

• PPP emerged as the single largest party; Yousuf Raza Gillani became PM.

---

XIV. Musharraf's Exit

• After the elections, Musharraf remained President (having already relinquished the Army Chief post), while PPP and PML-N together controlled the centre and the provinces.
• Facing the threat of impeachment proceedings, Musharraf resigned the presidency.
• Muhammad Mian Soomro became acting President.
• 6 September 2008: presidential election held; Asif Ali Zardari won with 481 votes and became President.
• This formally ended Musharraf's martial law/rule (1999–2008).

---

XV. Critical Appraisal

Following the dictator's playbook

• Like Zia, Musharraf sought legitimacy through a referendum and a local government system.
• Undermined the judiciary: sacking Iftikhar Chaudhry, then imposing emergency.
• Persecuted politicians: Benazir's death, Akbar Bugti's killing, Nawaz's forced exile, and a crackdown on PML-N.
• Built a King's Party (PML-Q), exactly as Ayub and Zia had done before him.
• 17th Constitutional Amendment: like Zia's 8th Amendment, this concentrated powers in the President's hands, including a version of Article 58(2)(b).

Positive contributions

1. Separation of judiciary from the executive at the district level — a first-time experiment in Pakistan, whose core principle survived even after his Devolution Plan was rolled back.
2. Police reforms, replacing the 1861 Police Act (though later reversed in Sindh and Balochistan).
3. Media liberalisation: issued many private TV licences, leading to a boom in private television channels and media houses.
4. "Enlightened Moderation":
   • A term coined by Musharraf, referring to promoting a moderate interpretation of Islam as opposed to a fundamentalist interpretation.
   • Unveiled at the 2002 OIC Summit in Malaysia (the lecture notes this timing, worth double-checking against the actual summit date).
   • Aimed at social liberalism and countering extremism, especially among low-literacy segments influenced by religious parties.
   • Faced fierce opposition from the MMA (Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal, an alliance of religious parties).
   • Side effect: intensified a women's rights vs religious elements debate; women in NGOs working for women's welfare faced significant criticism from religious quarters during this period.

Foreign policy: difficult choices

• Musharraf had little real choice given post-9/11 US pressure ("with us or against us").
• His "staying power" depended on close alliance with the US in the War on Terror — he could not afford to abandon it.
• At the same time, he could not abandon support for Kashmiri "freedom fighters" without risking his political credibility at home.
• Tried to pursue a more independent foreign policy by strengthening ties with China, an alternative major power, and refused to fully surrender Pakistan's influence in Afghanistan.
• Balancing act: pacify domestic critics without endangering his international standing as a champion of Enlightened Moderation — he was largely successful in this balancing act.

Economic policy

Challenges inherited:

• Heavy external and domestic debt
• High fiscal deficit, low revenue generation
• Rising poverty and unemployment
• Weak balance of payments, stagnant exports

Performance under Musharraf:

• GDP growth averaged ~6.3% per year — a healthy rate.
• Poverty (headcount ratio) fell from ~30% to ~15%.
• Unemployment fell from ~8.4% to ~6.5%.
• About 11.8 million new jobs created.

Why the improvement?

• Massive capital inflows post-9/11: US aid and multilateral donor funding, as Pakistan became a frontline War on Terror ally (mirroring the pattern seen under Zia's Afghan jihad alliance).
• US debt rescheduling/write-offs after 9/11 eased Pakistan's debt burden and improved the balance of payments.

Structural reforms:

• Fiscal consolidation by raising tax revenue — a serious effort to widen the tax net (traders, shopkeepers, exporters).
• Reduced expenditure: cutting subsidies, containing losses of public enterprises.
• Continued privatisation policy, easing the burden on the national exchequer.

⚠️ Balanced note: while headline economic indicators improved, this growth was substantially aid/debt-driven rather than purely structural, a pattern the lecturer explicitly draws parallel to Zia's era.

---

📊 Key Figures at a Glance

🗓️ Timeline

• 12 Oct 1999: coup; Nawaz ousted.
• 14 Oct 1999: PCO; Constitution suspended.
• 12 May 2000: SC validates coup, 3-year mandate.
• 2000: LGO 2000 issued.
• 2001: local body elections; Musharraf becomes President.
• 3 Dec 2000: ARD formed.
• 30 Apr 2002: referendum.
• 24 Aug 2002: LFO 2002.
• 10 Oct 2002: general elections; Jamali PM.
• Jun 2004: Jamali resigns; Shaukat Aziz eventually PM.
• 14 May 2006: Charter of Democracy, London.
• 26 Aug 2006: Akbar Bugti killed.
• Mar 2007: Iftikhar Chaudhry dismissed.
• 12 May 2007: Karachi Black Saturday.
• 3–10 Jul 2007: Lal Masjid operation.
• Jul 2007: Chaudhry restored as CJ.
• Oct 2007: Benazir returns; first assassination attempt.
• Nov 2007: Nawaz returns; emergency imposed; NA dissolved.
• Dec 2007: Benazir assassinated.
• 18 Feb 2008: general elections.
• Mar 2008: Gillani becomes PM.
• Aug 2008: Musharraf resigns.
• 6 Sep 2008: Zardari elected President.

---

⚠️ MCQ Traps

• Musharraf's coup was 12 October 1999; the PCO followed on 14 October.
• The Supreme Court gave Musharraf a 3-year mandate on 12 May 2000, using the doctrine of necessity (same principle as prior coup validations).
• The District Nazim system and separation of the DC's judicial powers were introduced via the LGO 2000, elections held 2001.
• ARD (2000) = PPP + PML-N alliance; Charter of Democracy (2006, London) is a separate, later document between the same two parties — don't confuse the two.
• Musharraf held the referendum on 30 April 2002, and issued the LFO on 24 August 2002; the 2002 general election was on 10 October 2002.
• PML-Q is Musharraf's "King's Party," carved from PML-N — parallel to how earlier dictators built their own parties.
• Iftikhar Chaudhry was dismissed in March 2007 and restored in July 2007 after the lawyers' movement.
• Karachi's "Black Saturday" (12 May 2007) is distinct from the Lal Masjid operation (3–10 July 2007) — two separate 2007 crises.
• Benazir Bhutto's assassination is widely dated 27 December 2007 in standard references — cross-check this against the lecture's stated date before an exam.
• The 17th Amendment mirrors the 8th Amendment's power concentration, including a version of Article 58(2)(b).
• "Enlightened Moderation" is a term coined by Musharraf, referring to moderate vs fundamentalist interpretations of Islam.
• 2008 election: PPP won via a sympathy wave, but PML-N came a close second — note PPP 128, PML-N ~91, PML-Q only 54 despite being the incumbent "King's Party."

---

✍️ Model Answer Outline

Q. Critically evaluate the Musharraf era (1999–2008).

1. Introduction: the coup, the 7-point agenda, and the general playbook of Pakistani military dictators (legitimacy via referendum, King's Party, constitutional amendment for power concentration).
2. Political developments: judicial validation, LGO 2000/devolution, ARD, 2002 elections/LFO, 17th Amendment, judicial crisis 2007, Lal Masjid, Benazir's assassination, emergency, 2008 elections, and Musharraf's exit.
3. Positives: separation of judiciary from executive, police reforms, media liberalisation, Enlightened Moderation, strong GDP/poverty/employment numbers.
4. Negatives: persecution of politicians, undermining the judiciary, aid-dependent economic growth, human rights violations in the War on Terror, rise in terrorism, Baloch insurgency after Akbar Bugti's killing.
5. Conclusion: a textbook military dictatorship — seizing power, entrenching it constitutionally, prolonging rule through a foreign-policy alliance (the War on Terror, as Zia used the Afghan jihad), and crushing opposition — with a mixed legacy of institutional reform alongside serious costs to democracy and human rights.

---

🧠 Self-Test Questions

1. What events led to Musharraf's takeover on 12 October 1999?
2. What were the seven points of Musharraf's initial agenda?
3. How did the Supreme Court validate Musharraf's coup, and what conditions did it attach?
4. Explain the key features of the Local Government Ordinance 2000 / Devolution Plan.
5. What was the ARD, and why did it fail to seriously challenge Musharraf?
6. How did Musharraf become President, and how did he seek legitimacy in 2002?
7. What was the Charter of Democracy, and who signed it?
8. Describe the 2007 judicial crisis and its two major flashpoints (Karachi, Lal Masjid).
9. What led to Benazir Bhutto's assassination, and what was its political impact?
10. What was "Enlightened Moderation," and how was it received?
11. Summarise Musharraf's economic record and explain the main driver of GDP growth in this period.
12. How did Musharraf's foreign policy choices after 9/11 reflect "tough choices" for Pakistan?

⚡ 60-Second Revision

12 Oct 1999 coup (Nawaz vs Musharraf/Ziauddin) → PCO 14 Oct • 7-point agenda: confidence, federation, economy, law & order, de-politicise, devolution, accountability • SC validates 12 May 2000, 3-year mandate • LGO 2000, elections 2001: District Nazim, DC judicial powers to judiciary (first-ever separation), DCO • ARD (PPP+PML-N) 3 Dec 2000, limited impact (exiled leadership) • President 2001; referendum 30 Apr 2002; LFO 24 Aug 2002; election 10 Oct 2002 → PML-Q (King's Party), Jamali PM → Shaukat Aziz • 9/11: "with us or against us" → U-turn on Taliban, frontline ally, new terrorism wave, human rights issues (missing persons, drone strikes) • Charter of Democracy, 14 May 2006, London (Nawaz + Benazir) • Akbar Bugti killed 26 Aug 2006 → Balochistan insurgency • Judicial crisis: Iftikhar Chaudhry dismissed Mar 2007, Karachi Black Saturday 12 May 2007 (58 dead), Lal Masjid 3–10 Jul 2007, CJ restored Jul 2007 • Benazir returns Oct 2007 (1st attempt), assassinated Dec 2007 • Emergency Nov 2007, NA dissolved, Nawaz returns • Election 18 Feb 2008: PPP 128, PML-N ~91, PML-Q 54 → Gillani PM • Musharraf resigns Aug 2008 → Zardari President 6 Sep 2008 (481 votes) • Appraisal: 17th Amendment (power grab like 8th), King's Party, persecution of politicians vs separation of judiciary/executive, police reform, media liberalisation, Enlightened Moderation (MMA opposition, women's rights debate); economy: 6.3% GDP growth, poverty 30%→15%, unemployment 8.4%→6.5%, 11.8M jobs — largely aid/debt-driven post-9/11 capital inflows

---

Next lecture: the Fourth Democratic Era, from 2008 onward.