Ayub Khan Regime — Part II (1962–1969)

🎯

Topic: Ayub Khan regime (1958–1969), Part II. Covers the 1965 presidential and general elections, the 1965 war, the Tashkent Declaration, Mujib's Six Points, the Agartala Conspiracy Case, foreign policy, the 1968–69 unrest and Ayub's fall, the "Decade of Development", and a critical appraisal.

CSS relevance: 🔥 Very high. The Six Points, the Tashkent Declaration, the 1965 war, the Decade of Development / 22 families and "Evaluate Ayub's era" are classic questions.

🗺️ Overview

---

I. Presidential Election (2 January 1965)

• The electoral college was the 80,000 Basic Democrats (40,000 per wing).
  • They were elected members of the union, tehsil, district and divisional councils. There were about 7,300 union councils, each with 10 elected members.
• Candidates:
  • Ayub Khan, for the Convention Muslim League.
  • Miss Fatima Jinnah, for the Combined Opposition Parties (COP), a coalition of five parties:
    1. Awami League
    2. Council Muslim League
    3. Jamaat-e-Islami
    4. National Awami Party (Wali Khan faction)
    5. Nizam-e-Islam Party
• Result:
  • Ayub won about 62% of the electoral votes; Fatima Jinnah about 36%.
  • Fatima Jinnah swept major cities, such as Karachi and Dhaka. Ayub also faced discontent in East Pakistan.
  • But Ayub won a clear majority, with most of his votes from West Pakistan.
• Aftermath:
  • The COP rejected the result, accusing Ayub of rigging and of using administrative and bureaucratic influence over the small electoral college.
  • Its protests and demonstrations won little public support, were easily handled by the police, and fizzled out.

---

II. General Election (21 March 1965)

• The 1962 Constitution provided for an indirectly elected, unicameral National Assembly of 156 seats:
  • 150 general seats (single-member constituencies): 75 East + 75 West.
  • 6 women's seats: 3 East + 3 West.
• Electorate: the same 80,000 Basic Democrats, making it an indirect election.

Result (150 general seats)

---

III. The 1965 War with India

• A full-fledged war from August to September 1965.
• Cause: Kashmir.
  • Operation Gibraltar (August 1965): Pakistan infiltrated forces into Indian-held Jammu & Kashmir to spark an uprising against Indian rule.
  • India said the war was started by Pakistan.
  • India then attacked across the international border towards Lahore on 6 September 1965, now marked as Defence Day in Pakistan.
• Scale:
  • Thousands of casualties on both sides, civilian and military.
  • The largest armoured (tank) battles since WWII, especially the Battle of Chawinda (Sialkot sector).
• Ceasefire: through UN Security Council Resolution 211. Hostilities ended around 22–23 September 1965.
• Diplomatic role: both the Soviet Union and the USA intervened. The USSR then brokered peace talks at Tashkent.

---

IV. Tashkent Declaration (10 January 1966)

• Talks were hosted by the Soviet Union at Tashkent (Uzbekistan) from 4–10 January 1966, to create a permanent settlement.
• Mediator: Soviet Premier Alexei Kosygin.
• Signatories: Indian PM Lal Bahadur Shastri and President Ayub Khan.

Salient features

1. Restoration of the pre-war position: both armies to withdraw to their positions before 5 August 1965.
   • This set a baseline for boundaries and reduced tension.
   • Pakistan returned the territory it had captured.
2. Non-interference in each other's internal affairs.
3. No hostile propaganda: both sides would discourage propaganda against each other, to build mutual respect.
4. Orderly repatriation of prisoners of war on humanitarian grounds.
5. Improvement of bilateral relations through constructive dialogue, and restoring diplomatic relations to rebuild trust and cooperation.
6. Restoration of trade and economic relations to their pre-war status, to promote stability and shared prosperity.
7. No use of force: disputes to be settled by peaceful means.
8. Respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity.

Outcome

• The ceasefire was consolidated, troops withdrew, POWs were exchanged, and diplomatic and economic ties were restored.

Reactions

• India: Shastri died of a heart attack in Tashkent the night after signing (11 January 1966).
• Pakistan: a strong public backlash.
  • People believed the army had won on the battlefield, but Ayub "lost at the negotiating table" by giving back captured areas.
  • Z.A. Bhutto (Foreign Minister) opposed it. He left the cabinet in 1966 and founded the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) in 1967.
  • The Declaration became one of the main causes of Ayub's downfall.

Critical appraisal

• It gave temporary relief by ending the immediate conflict, but did not resolve Kashmir, the root cause of the war.
• It failed to deliver a lasting, comprehensive solution, so tensions and wars continued (1971, Kargil 1999).

---

V. Mujib's Six Points (1966)

• Context:
  • After Tashkent, internal unrest grew.
  • The EBDO ban on politicians expired in 1966, and parties re-emerged with intense activity.
• Sheikh Mujibur Rahman presented the Six Points in 1966 (announced in Lahore, February 1966), and launched the Six-Point Movement.

The Six Points

1. True federation:
   • Based on the Lahore Resolution (1940).
   • A parliamentary system with supremacy of the legislature, directly elected on universal adult franchise.
   • This was against the 1962 system of indirect elections.
2. Federal subjects limited to Defence and Foreign Affairs.
   • All other, residuary subjects would go to the federating states.
   • It meant a weak centre and strong provinces, a loose federation or confederation.
3. Currency:
   • Two separate but freely convertible currencies for the two wings.
   • Or one currency, with constitutional safeguards to stop the flight of capital from East to West Pakistan.
   • A separate reserve bank, and separate fiscal and monetary policy, for East Pakistan.
4. Taxation: the power to levy and collect taxes would rest with the federating units. The centre would get only a share to meet its expenditure.
5. Foreign exchange and trade:
   • Separate foreign exchange accounts for each wing.
   • The centre's foreign exchange needs to be met equally by both wings.
   • Units could set up trade links with foreign countries.
6. Separate militia / paramilitary force for East Pakistan. (The lecture adds that the Navy headquarters was to be in East Pakistan.)

Reactions

• East Pakistan parties and people endorsed them.
• West Pakistani politicians and the Ayub government called them a threat to Pakistan's integrity: a confederation, not a federation.
• The government gave no positive response. Mujib launched a mass-contact campaign to build pressure.
• Underlying grievance: Mujib believed East Pakistan earned more (from jute exports) while West Pakistan lived on its earnings, so its wealth should stay in the East.

---

VI. Agartala Conspiracy Case (1968)

• A sedition case brought by the Ayub government in 1968 against Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and 34 others.
• Allegation: Mujib's associates met Indian military officials in Agartala (Tripura, India) to seek Indian support for Bangladesh's independence.
• A special tribunal of three judges tried the case:
  • Chairman: Justice S.A. Rahman (non-Bengali).
  • Members: M.R. Khan and Maksumul Hakim (Bengalis).
• In the face of a mass movement, the government withdrew the case on 22 February 1969.
• The accused were released the next day.
  • A huge reception was held at the Race Course Maidan, Dhaka, where Mujib was given the title "Bangabandhu" (Friend of Bengal).
• Effect: the case made Mujib a hero, and East Pakistan turned firmly against the government.

---

VII. Foreign Policy under Ayub

Alliance with the USA

• Ayub aligned Pakistan with the USA and allowed American access to air bases in Pakistan, notably Badaber near Peshawar.
  • Spy flights were launched from there over the Soviet Union.
  • The U-2 incident (May 1960) exposed this, and angered the USSR.
• The US had first sought bases in Liaquat's time and was refused. Access was later granted, and in Ayub's era the bases became fully operational.
• As C-in-C and then President, Ayub built strategic and military ties with the US against regional communism and Soviet influence.
  • He was a stalwart of the Western camp (SEATO, CENTO).

Friendship with China

• Sino–Pakistan Boundary Agreement (1963) (the lecture says 1962) settled the border and began close friendship with China.
• The US did not like this, and relations with Washington began to deteriorate.

Strain with the US and USSR

• The US alignment worsened relations with the USSR.
• 1961–65: Ayub lost much of the support of Presidents John F. Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson, as they sought closer ties with India (especially after the 1962 Sino–Indian war).
• 1965 war: President Johnson imposed an arms embargo on both countries, even though Pakistan was a SEATO/CENTO ally. This showed US displeasure with Ayub.
• Pattern:
  • 1958–62: very close to the USA; cold with the USSR.
  • After 1962: close to China; ties with the US strained.
  • After 1965: Ayub improved ties with the USSR (Tashkent).

---

VIII. Political Unrest (1968–69) & Ayub's Fall

East Pakistan

• A democratic mass uprising in 1969, led by students and backed by the Awami League and NAP. It was against:
  • military rule and political repression
  • the Agartala Conspiracy Case
  • the imprisonment of Mujib.
• The unrest began in 1966 with the Six-Point Movement, and gained momentum in early 1969.

Round Table Conference (1969)

• Ayub called an RTC with the opposition to find a solution.
• Mujib presented a draft constitution based on the Six Points.
• Mujib's political backing was very strong, so the talks brought no result.

West Pakistan

• The Democratic Action Committee (DAC), a coalition to restore democracy, ran a similar campaign against Ayub.
  • Its moving spirit and organiser was Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan.
• Z.A. Bhutto's PPP and student and labour movements added to the pressure.

Fall

• 25 March 1969: Ayub resigned and handed power to Gen. Yahya Khan (Army C-in-C).
  • Martial law was declared again.
  • This violated his own 1962 Constitution, under which the Speaker should have taken over.

---

IX. The "Decade of Development" (1958–68)

In 1968, Ayub celebrated ten years in power as the "Decade of Development".

Achievements

• Political stability and continuity: one government for 11 years (27 Oct 1958 – 25 Mar 1969).
• GDP growth averaged about 5.8%, with some years at 8–9%.
• Manufacturing grew at about 8.5%, faster than at any other time in Pakistan's history.
• New industries: automobile and cement.
• Infrastructure:
  • Mangla Dam (1967), and Tarbela Dam started
  • canals and power projects.
• Pakistan's space programme launched (SUPARCO, 1961).
• Agriculture: the Green Revolution:
  • Land reforms (1959)
  • consolidation of holdings
  • strict measures against hoarding
  • rural credit and rural works programmes
  • higher procurement prices
  • more allocation for agriculture
  • high-yield (improved) seeds, fertilisers and tubewells.
  • Result: higher yield per acre and new crops.

Criticism: the "22 families"

• Dr Mahbub ul Haq (Chief Economist, Planning Commission) said in 1968 that economic power was concentrated in 22 families. They controlled:
  • about 66% of industrial assets
  • about 80–87% of banking.
• The benefits of growth did not reach ordinary citizens. Inequality grew between classes and between East and West Pakistan, which fed the 1968–69 unrest.

---

X. Critical Appraisal of the Ayub Era

Positives

• Political stability: after years of governments changing every few months, one regime lasted 11 years.
• Development and progress in industry, agriculture and exports.
• Good relations with both the USA and China.
• The Indus Waters Treaty, the new capital (Islamabad), and Basic Democracies as the first local government system.

Negatives

• Authoritarian, one-man rule, not democracy.
• Militarised Pakistani politics, and set the precedent for future coups.
• The 1962 Constitution was tailor-made for Ayub's needs.
• Basic Democracies were used for political ends. The 80,000 BDs elected Ayub himself.
• Economic inequality: the 22 families, and the East–West disparity.
• The Tashkent backlash.
• Failed to handle the 1966–69 unrest politically. He used force instead of dialogue.
• Handed power to another dictator (Yahya) instead of holding elections and transferring power to an elected government.
  • Had he done so, Pakistan might have been demilitarised, and the 1971 tragedy avoided.
  • Instead, military rule continued, and Yahya followed the same policies.

---

📊 Key Figures at a Glance

🗓️ Timeline

• 1963: Sino–Pakistan Boundary Agreement.
• 2 Jan 1965: presidential election; Ayub defeats Fatima Jinnah.
• 21 Mar 1965: National Assembly election; Convention ML wins 120 seats.
• Aug 1965: Operation Gibraltar.
• 6 Sept 1965: India attacks Lahore; full war.
• Sept 1965: Battle of Chawinda; UNSC Resolution 211; ceasefire.
• 4–10 Jan 1966: Tashkent talks.
• 10 Jan 1966: Declaration signed.
• 11 Jan 1966: Shastri dies.
• Feb 1966: Mujib announces the Six Points.
• 1966: EBDO disqualifications expire.
• 1967: Bhutto founds the PPP.
• 1968: Agartala Conspiracy Case; "Decade of Development" celebrated; Mahbub ul Haq's "22 families" statement.
• Late 1968 – early 1969: mass movement in both wings; DAC formed.
• 22 Feb 1969: Agartala case withdrawn.
• 23 Feb 1969: Mujib becomes "Bangabandhu".
• Feb–Mar 1969: Round Table Conference fails.
• 25 Mar 1969: Ayub resigns; Yahya imposes martial law.

---

⚠️ MCQ Traps

• The 1965 presidential election was held on 2 January 1965. It was indirect: 80,000 BDs voted.
• Fatima Jinnah was the COP candidate, backed by five parties including the Jamaat-e-Islami and Awami League.
• Ayub's party was the Convention Muslim League; the opposition's was the Council Muslim League.
• The 1962 NA had 156 seats (150 + 6 women), elected indirectly.
• Operation Gibraltar was the infiltration into Kashmir, not the name of the war.
• The ceasefire came through UNSC Resolution 211.
• Tashkent was hosted by the USSR (Kosygin), not the USA or UN. It was signed by Shastri and Ayub.
• Tashkent's withdrawal line was positions before 5 August 1965.
• Shastri died in Tashkent the day after signing.
• The Six Points came in 1966. Point 2 limited the centre to Defence and Foreign Affairs only.
• The Agartala case was filed in 1968 and withdrawn on 22 Feb 1969. Bangabandhu was the title given afterwards.
• The DAC was led and organised by Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan.
• Ayub resigned on 25 March 1969 and gave power to Yahya, not the Speaker, against his own constitution.
• The "22 families" remark came from Dr Mahbub ul Haq.

---

✍️ Model Answer Outlines

Q1. Critically evaluate the Ayub Khan era (1958–69).

1. Introduction: the first military ruler, from the 1958 coup to his resignation in 1969.
2. Achievements:
   • stability
   • the Decade of Development (5.8% GDP, 8.5% manufacturing, Green Revolution, dams)
   • the IWT, Islamabad, Basic Democracies
   • ties with the US and China.
3. Failures:
   • authoritarianism, a tailor-made constitution, the BD electoral college
   • the 22 families and East–West disparity
   • the 1965 war and Tashkent backlash
   • the Six Points and Agartala case alienating East Pakistan.
4. Fall: the 1968–69 unrest, the RTC's failure, and power handed to Yahya.
5. Conclusion: "growth without equity or democracy". It planted the seeds of 1971 and of military dominance.

Q2. Discuss the Six Points of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. Why were they seen as a threat to Pakistan's integrity?

• List and explain the six points.
• Background: economic disparity, the 1965 war leaving the East undefended, the BD system.
• Threat: a confederation with separate currencies, taxation, trade and militia, and a weak centre.
• Impact: the Agartala case, the 1969 uprising, the 1970 election, 1971.

Q3. Evaluate the Tashkent Declaration.

• Terms: withdrawal, non-interference, no propaganda, POWs, trade, diplomacy.
• Positive: ended the war and restored normal relations.
• Negative: Kashmir untouched; a public sense of betrayal; Bhutto's exit and the PPP; a factor in Ayub's fall.

---

🧠 Self-Test Questions

1. Who contested the 1965 presidential election? Who backed Fatima Jinnah, and what was the result?
2. How was the National Assembly elected in 1965, and what was the party position?
3. What was Operation Gibraltar? How did the 1965 war end?
4. List the main terms of the Tashkent Declaration. Why was it unpopular in Pakistan?
5. State Mujib's Six Points. Why did West Pakistan oppose them?
6. What was the Agartala Conspiracy Case, and what was its effect?
7. How did Pakistan's relations with the USA, China and the USSR change under Ayub?
8. What were the causes of the 1968–69 mass movement?
9. What were the achievements of the "Decade of Development"? What was the "22 families" criticism?
10. Give a critical appraisal of Ayub's rule.

⚡ 60-Second Revision

2 Jan 1965: Ayub (Convention ML, ~62%) beats Fatima Jinnah (COP: AL, Council ML, JI, NAP-Wali, Nizam-e-Islam, ~36%) via 80,000 BDs • 21 Mar 1965: NA of 156 (150 + 6); Convention ML 120 • 1965 war: Operation Gibraltar (Aug) → 6 Sept Lahore → Chawinda tank battle → UNSC Res 211 ceasefire • Tashkent (4–10 Jan 1966; Kosygin, Shastri, Ayub): withdraw to pre-5 Aug 1965 lines, non-interference, no propaganda, POWs, trade, no force; Shastri dies; Pakistani backlash; Bhutto exits and forms PPP (1967); Kashmir unresolved • Six Points 1966: true federation; centre = defence + foreign affairs only; separate currency/reserve; taxes with units; separate foreign exchange and trade; East militia • Agartala case 1968 (Mujib + 34; tribunal S.A. Rahman) → withdrawn 22 Feb 1969 → "Bangabandhu" • Foreign policy: US bases (Badaber, U-2 1960) → China boundary 1963 → US embargo 1965 • 1969 uprising (students, AL, NAP); RTC fails; DAC (Nasrullah Khan) → 25 Mar 1969 Ayub hands over to Yahya • Decade of Development: 5.8% GDP, 8.5% industry, autos and cement, Mangla/Tarbela, SUPARCO, Green Revolution • 22 families (Mahbub ul Haq): 66% industry, ~80–87% banking • Appraisal: stability and growth vs authoritarianism, militarisation, inequality, handing over to Yahya

---

Next lecture: Salient features of the 1962 Constitution, and its comparison with the 1956 Constitution.