CSS Prepare

compulsory · CSS study notes

Government Structure Across Constitutions (1956, 1962, 1973)

Overview

Quick-reference comparison of how power was structured in Pakistan's three constitutions (1956, 1962, 1973). Useful for MCQs and structural comparison questions.


1) Government Structure — 1956 Constitution (Parliamentary)

President (Head of State)

  • Restrictions: Muslim, over 40, PM must be from National Assembly
  • Powers: Chooses PM; emergency powers — can dissolve National Assembly
  • Linked to: Federal & Provincial Courts

Prime Minister (Head of Government)

  • Powers: Chooses Cabinet
  • Restriction: Cabinet must be from National Assembly

Cabinet

  • Powers: Advises President
  • Restriction: Advice only
  • Linked to: Islamic Committee (advice/review role on legislation)

Legislature

  • Unicameral — National Assembly: 1 house, 300 members, elected by adults over 21
  • Provincial Assembly: East Pakistan as one body; West Pakistan as single "One Unit" (4 provinces merged), elected same way

2) Government Structure — 1962 Constitution (Presidential + Basic Democracies)

President

  • Powers: Appoints Provincial Governors; appoints PDAC members
  • System: Elected indirectly through Basic Democrats (not direct adult franchise)

5 Provincial Governments

  • Powers: Run the provinces
  • Restrictions: Must obey President; must consult PDAC

2 Provincial Development Advisory Councils (PDAC)

  • One each for East & West Pakistan

Divisional Councils

  • Headed by Divisional Commissioner (bureaucrat, not elected); not directly elected — civil servants chosen by/coordinated with PDAC

District Councils

  • Headed by Deputy Commissioner; some members elected

Local Committees / Union Councils

  • Only directly elected tier ("Basic Democrats") — ~80,000 across the country
  • These indirectly elected the President and Assembly members

Key features: Presidential system; unicameral legislatures at centre & provinces; institutionalized military role (legalized generals as PM/Defence Minister)


3) Government Structure — 1973 Constitution (Parliamentary, currently in force)

President (Head of State — largely ceremonial)

  • Restrictions: Muslim
  • Elected indirectly by Parliament + Provincial Assemblies (electoral college)

Prime Minister (Head of Government — real executive power)

  • Elected by majority of National Assembly
  • Powers: Appoints Chief Justice (on advice/process), runs the government

Cabinet

  • Powers: Advises PM
  • Restriction: Advice only
  • Linked to: Islamic Council (advises only on legislation vis-a-vis Islamic injunctions)

Judiciary

  • Separate judiciary; judges elected/appointed for fixed tenure (5 years reference in notes, subject to later amendments like 18th/19th which changed appointment process)

Legislature — Bicameral (Two Houses)

  • Senate — upper house, equal provincial representation (protects smaller provinces)
  • National Assembly — lower house, 200 members (original 1973 figure; later increased via amendments)

Provincial Assembly seat distribution (original 1973 allocation)

  • Punjab: 240 seats
  • Sindh: 100 seats
  • NWFP (now KP): 80 seats
  • Balochistan: 40 seats

Quick Comparison Table

Feature195619621973
SystemParliamentaryPresidentialParliamentary
Real executivePMPresidentPM
FranchiseDirect (adult)Indirect (Basic Democrats)Direct (adult)
LegislatureUnicameralUnicameralBicameral (Senate + NA)
Province structureOne Unit (West Pakistan merged)One Unit continuedFour provinces restored
Survived2 years7 yearsStill in force (with suspensions)

Exam Angle

  • This comparison table is exam gold for "trace constitutional evolution" questions — shows the pendulum swing: parliamentary (1956) → presidential/controlled (1962) → parliamentary again (1973), each shift driven by military intervention or civilian backlash against concentrated power.