CSS Prepare

compulsory · CSS study notes

Relations with the United States

Official CSS Syllabus Item: Pakistan's External Affairs → Relations with the United States — part of 40 Marks

Answer Structure

  1. Historical background 2. Current status/key developments 3. Areas of cooperation 4. Areas of tension 5. Pakistan's strategic interest 6. Way forward

Historical Arc

  • Close Cold War alliance → post-9/11 "War on Terror" partnership (with major domestic security fallout) → post-2021 Afghan withdrawal relative cooling → renewed engagement interest as of 2026

Current Status

  • Punjab CM Maryam Nawaz Sharif has publicly called for "a new chapter in Pakistan-US relations" — signals interest in improved ties
  • US remains a major (though less dominant than in Cold War/War on Terror eras) security and economic partner

Key Dynamics

  • US continues sanctions-architecture influence over regional actors (relevant to the UAE-Iran frozen assets controversy)
  • Pakistan's deepening ties with China create a persistent structural tension in the US relationship, given US-China strategic rivalry
  • US role in the 2026 Iran war and Gulf security indirectly shapes Pakistan's position, given Pakistan's new Gulf defense commitments (Makkah pact)

August 2026 Update: Counterterrorism Cooperation

  • 4th US-Pakistan Counterterrorism Dialogue held in Washington, D.C. (4 Aug 2026), led by US Coordinator for Counterterrorism Amb. Gregory LoGerfo and Pakistan's Special Secretary Amb. Nabeel Munir
  • Both sides affirmed joint resolve against ISIS-K, al-Qa'ida (AQ), TTP, and the Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA) — a frequently testable named list
  • Discussions covered threat environment, border security, and disrupting terrorist facilitation networks
  • Shows CT cooperation continuing as an operational track even while broader political ties stay modest

The Trump-Era Reset (2025–26)

  • Relations moved from Biden-era "benign neglect" to active engagement after Trump's second-term inauguration — driven largely by personal/military channels rather than institutional ones
  • Field Marshal Asim Munir (Chief of Army Staff/Chief of Defence Forces) has held frequent direct meetings with Trump — an unprecedented White House lunch hosted by Trump for Munir (2025) symbolized the reset
  • Pakistan's traditional US playbook — strong personal relations, public praise of American leaders/generals — has worked especially well on Trump, per analysts (Hudson Institute)
  • May 2025 India-Pakistan conflict: Trump claimed US mediation ended the war; Pakistan credited this publicly, while India (PM Modi, FM Jaishankar) insisted the ceasefire was purely bilateral — a live, testable dispute in the narrative
  • 2026 Iran War mediation: Pakistan became a key broker between the US/Israel and Iran despite not recognizing Israel and having a fraught history with Trump — analysts describe this as Pakistan "speaking Trump's language" (Washington Post) to secure relevance
  • Pakistan joined the US-backed "Board of Peace" for Gaza stabilization (invitation accepted late 2025) — reinforces the pragmatic, transactional character of the relationship rather than a revival of Cold War-style alliance
  • Analysts caution the "upswing" is unlikely to be durable given the relationship's historical rollercoaster pattern (aid cuts, "lies and deceit" tweet in 2018, post-2021 Afghan withdrawal cooling)

Balancing China and the US: The Minerals Test Case

  • Since Feb 2026, critical minerals have become the sharpest test of Pakistan's balancing act: Energy Minister Ali Pervaiz Malik joined US Secretary of State Marco Rubio's Critical Minerals Ministerial (Feb 2026); Washington approved $1.3bn financing for the Reko Diq copper-gold project (7 Feb 2026)
  • Pakistan invited both China and the US to its own Pakistan Minerals Investment Forum (PMIF), April 2026 in Islamabad — explicit strategy of not choosing sides, seeking $6–8bn in annual mineral export potential from multiple partners (also Australia, Canada)
  • Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb summarized the strategy: Pakistan sits at "a constructive intersection" of renewed US ties, time-tested China relations, and Gulf/Saudi cooperation — a deliberate multi-vector positioning, not exclusive alignment
  • China's assessment (per South Asian Voices analysts): Beijing is not worried by the US-Pakistan "honeymoon" — US minerals/energy investment is unlikely to displace China's entrenched role in Pakistani infrastructure, energy, and defense; Islamabad has reassured Beijing that US cooperation (e.g., reported rare-earths shipments to the US, Oct 2025) won't tread on Chinese interests
  • Structural constraint on the US side (CSIS analysis): Washington faces its own dilemma — deepening ties with Pakistan risks friction with India, which the US values more strategically (Indo-Pacific/Quad partner); India's absence from the March 2026 Indo-Pacific Energy Security Ministerial was read as a signal of this tension

The BLA Complication

  • The Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA) directly threatens both Chinese (CPEC/Gwadar) and now US (Reko Diq, minerals) investment interests in Balochistan — the same province hosts both countries' flagship projects
  • Repeated BLA attacks on Chinese nationals (see Neighbors → China page for detail) demonstrate Pakistan's limited counter-insurgency capacity, a factor analysts say both Beijing and Washington factor into their risk calculus but have so far chosen to absorb rather than exit
  • Analysts (Al Jazeera, Feb 2026): both China and the US are aware of the security risk profile in Balochistan — "these are government-to-government deals... neither the US nor China will pull out their investment" despite periodic violence
  • Exam-relevant framing: Balochistan has become the literal ground where Pakistan's China-US balancing act plays out — both powers' economic bets sit in the same insecure province, giving Pakistan leverage but also exposing it to simultaneous pressure from both capitals to fix security

Exam Angle

  • Classic essay question: "Can Pakistan balance close ties with both China and the US simultaneously?" — discuss multi-alignment strategy (minerals diplomacy as the live case study), economic dependency on both, the India factor complicating US calculus, and the BLA/Balochistan security question as the shared vulnerability both powers must tolerate

MCQ Traps

  • Reko Diq financing ($1.3bn) approved 7 Feb 2026; PMIF forum held 8–9 April 2026 — distinct events, don't conflate dates
  • Pakistan's ceasefire-mediation credit (May 2025) is disputed by India — a nuance frequently tested

Self-Test Questions

  1. What is the current state of US-Pakistan counterterrorism cooperation, and which groups are jointly named as threats?
  2. How does Pakistan's relationship with China create structural tension in its US relationship?
  3. What signals has Pakistan sent about wanting to reset ties with Washington in 2026?

Missing Building Block: The 2025 US-Pakistan Trade & Oil Deal (background to the 2026 "reset")

  • 31 July 2025: Pakistan and the US finalised a "landmark" trade agreement — Trump announced a parallel deal for the two countries to jointly develop Pakistan's oil reserves, with the US "choosing the oil company" to lead the partnership
  • Tariffs: Pakistan accepted a 19% US tariff on its exports (down from a threatened 29% reciprocal tariff announced in April 2025) in exchange for duty-free US access to Pakistan's market across 4,100+ tariff lines
  • Sectors named for cooperation: energy, mines and minerals, IT, cryptocurrency — directly setting up the 2026 "minerals diplomacy" track (Reko Diq financing, PMIF) described above
  • Political dimension: Field Marshal Asim Munir's June 2025 White House meeting with Trump (where they also discussed the India-Pakistan and Iran-Israel tensions) is widely credited by analysts with helping unlock the deal — reinforcing the "personal/military-channel diplomacy" pattern described in the Trump-Era Reset section above
  • Comparative angle: analysts noted Pakistan secured comparatively favourable tariff treatment (19%) even as India faced steeper US tariffs in the same period — cited as an example of Pakistan "outmaneuvering" India in Trump's tariff framework despite India's larger economy, a useful comparative/analytical point for an essay on Pakistan's 2025-26 diplomatic repositioning

Exam Angle

This trade deal is the economic precursor to everything described above under "Balancing China and the US" — the Reko Diq financing and PMIF forum are direct follow-throughs of commitments made in this July 2025 agreement, not standalone 2026 initiatives.